Natalie Portman in 'hands of BDS' after pulling out of Israeli award: Minister

The actor said she could not 'in good conscience' take part in the Israeli award ceremony after 'distressing' events in region

Actor Natalie Portman at Annual Academy Awards in 2011 (AFP)

Osha Mohamed

Friday 20 April 2018 

Israel's culture minister said actor Natalie Portman had fallen “into the hands of the BDS supporters” after the Jerusalem-born actress cancelled her trip to Israel, where she was meant to receive the “Jewish Nobel” prize.

The Oscar-award winning actor was due to be the recipient of the Genesis Prize, dubbed the “Jewish Nobel”, but withdrew from the ceremony citing extreme distress at “recent events in Israel”.

“She [Portman] does not feel comfortable participating in any public events in Israel... she cannot in good conscience move forward with the ceremony,” said the actor's representative.

The Genesis Prize Foundation said it was “very saddened” by the decision. It later announced that it would be cancelling the ceremony altogether.

Miri Regev, Israel’s culture minister, criticised the decision, saying: “I was sorry to hear that Natalie Portman fell into the hands of the BDS supporters."

“Portman, a Jewish actress born in Israel, joins those who describe the successful, wondrous founding of the state of Israel as ‘a tale of darkness and darkness'.”

Oren Hazan, an Israeli politican and legislator, has stated that the actress should be stripped of her Israeli citizenship for her decision and described the incident as "complete craziness." 

Portman's directorial debut was the film A Tale of Love and Darkness, adapted from a memoir by an Israeli novelist, depicting the birth of Israel.

However, other figures online have commended the decision citing Israeli use of force against Palestinian protesters in Gaza that have left dozens dead and thousands injured.

Eugene Gu, MD

✔@eugenegu

Natalie Portman, a dual American and Israeli citizen, takes a moral stand against the massacres in Gaza. Thank you. https://twitter.com/thr/status/987107930846543874 …

7:53 PM - Apr 19, 2018

• 3,082
• 834 people are talking about this

Twitter Ads info and privacy

Eoin Higgins

✔@EoinHiggins_

This is good, glad to see Natalie Portman being cognizant that her presence could potentially contribute to the normalization of Israel’s human rights abuses https://twitter.com/dgreenbaum/status/987077698903212036 …

6:07 PM - Apr 19, 2018

• 601
• 155 people are talking about this

Twitter Ads info and privacy

Both the United Nations and European Union have recently called for investigations into the Israeli army’s use of live ammunition on Palestinians during the “Great March of Return” protests that have been taking place in Gaza since 30 March.

Thirty-six Palestinians have been killed and 4,279 wounded by Israeli forces since the protests started four weeks ago.

Israeli politican Rachel Azaria said Portman's decision was a reflection of changing attitudes towards Israel among US Jews.

“Natalie Portman’s cancellation should be a warning sign,” she tweeted.

“She’s totally one of us, identifies with her Jewishness and Israeliness. She’s expressing the voices of many in US Jewry, and particularly those of the younger generation. This is a community that was always a significant anchor for the State of Israel and the price of losing it is likely to be too high.”

In a statement, the Genesis Prize Foundation said its organisers “fear that Ms Portman’s decision will cause our philanthropic initiative to be politicised, something we have worked hard for the past five years to avoid”.

The prize was launched in 2013 with the purpose of recognising Jewish achievement and contributions to humanity.

When it was announced that Portman would be the 2018 recipient, the actor stated she was proud of her “Israeli roots and Jewish heritage”.

A source at the foundation told Haaretz that Portman did not intend to return the $1m cash prize that comes with the award. Nor was she looking to return the additional grant promised by an Israeli philanthropist.

It is reportedly typical for the recipient to announce which charities they are donating the prize money to six months after the ceremony.

The ceremony was meant to take place on 28 June.

The actor had planned to donate the money to international and Israeli organisations dedicated to women’s causes and had already notified the foundation of this decision.

In 2009, the actor joined others in protesting calls to boycott the Toronto International Film Festival for its staging of a Tel Aviv-themed event. 

Following the re-election of Benjamin Netanyahu in 2015, Portman stated that she was “very, very upset and disappointed”.

Citing caution in her criticism, the actor added: “I feel like there are some people who become prominent, and then it’s out in the foreign press. You know, shit on Israel. I do not. I don’t want to do that.”